nothingvanilla header image 2

Port Arthur – the elephant in the room.

February 27th, 2011 · 2 Comments

180 years worth of harsh and brutal history is a lot to absorb in two days,  even so Port Arthur’s famous historical convict settlement makes for a lasting impression.

There are many hours to be had exploring  the crumbled ruins and derelict buildings. Prison cells so  small that spending one second too long is enough to bring on a claustrophobic related anxiety attack.  Most entertaining is the night ghost tour where you are treated to theatrical stories of hauntings and ghost sightings of the past.   Flickering lanterns add to the effect and it’s not long before you both welcome and dread the idea of feeling an ice cold hand touch your shoulder.

Aside from the historical convict settlement, Port Arthur is also well known  for the 1996 massacre, whereby a gunman sadly killed 35 people and injured 21.  Understandably, no one in Port Arthur  utters a world about the massacre.  The only physical evidence that remains of this fateful day  is a little memorial garden and the shell of the Broad Arrow Cafe – the cafe in which many lost their lives.

My observations and learnings from my two days in Port Arthur? Well, prisoners were subjected to harsh  punishment and an inhumane reform system,  hundreds of people died over the decades,  some say that there are many Port Arthur ghosts and that the Parsonage is one of the most haunted sites in the world – it seems that Port Arthur is a place of pain and torture.  But what of the massacre?  Are there no ghosts here too, was this not a place of pain and torture? Anyone noticed  the elephant in the room?

For me, the most spine chilling moment at Port Arthur  occurred when I passed through the doors of what was once the Broad Arrow Cafe-  I was so overwhelmed with emotion that I had to leave almost as quickly as I had entered.   Does a place have to have ghosts for it to be considered haunted?  I say no. I dispute that the Parsonage is one of the most haunted sites in the world – I say the Broad Arrow Cafe is.

Whilst I think it would be wrong to promote the massacre as a tourist attraction,  I do think it raises an interesting question, how long does it take before a society can openly talk with emotional distance about a violent or calamitous event? The tour guides at Port Arthur were certainly quite cheerful discussing torture and killings some 100 years hence. But how long does it really take –   5 years, 10 years, 50 years? Perhaps society can only speak freely when everyone who knew the victims is dead? However we know it’s not that simple, the perceived guilt or innocence of the victims seems to mix things up even more.  If 35 gangsters had been killed in a gangland attack no doubt within a short space of time the site would form the highlight of any tour to Port Arthur.

Do we as a society revere the innocent and scorn the guilty, in death as in life? The elephant at Port Arthur would suggest we do.

Tags: musings

2 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Robyn // Feb 28, 2011 at 9:58 am

    Kath, although not your usual style of writing (humorous and witty etc), this is a beautifully written piece and does raise a very pertinent question i.e. how long until we can talk about the massacre. As a ‘Taswegian’ I found your article thought-provoking and reflective. I was present at the birth of my twin nephews on 28 April 1996, and as we were relishing the newborns, a midwife entered the room and turned on the TV so we could hear the newsflash and witness the tragedy that was taking place. I will never forget that day …

  • 2 Chantal Smith // Jun 15, 2015 at 10:46 am

    “How long does it take before a society can openly talk with emotional distance about a violent or calamitous event?” Good question Katherine. I don’t think true 100% emotional distance can ever be achieved when it comes to such events, at least not when human lives are involved. There are some who can forgive more easily than others though, we can all seek understanding and look for explanations as to why things occur but justifications and degrees of right and wrong, forgiveness and redemption are different matters. Great blog Katherine, I hope you write again soon.

Leave a Comment